Semiconductor industry of Malaysia drives nation’s E&E industry & industrial development
Lai Kit Siang’s Rule Book of Diversion - Semuanya Salah MCA!  

Don’t emotionally oppose the ECRL for the sake of populism devoid of scientific facts

On Wednesday    07-04-2021 18:26:00

7 April 2021


Press statement by MCA Youth Spokesperson Jacob Lee Yee Yuan


Don’t emotionally oppose the ECRL for the sake of populism devoid of scientific facts



Chronology of the East Coast Rail Link (ECRL):

During the administration of Pakatan Harapan (PH), the government had reviewed and shelved various mega projects undertaken during Barisan Nasional’s (BN) administration. These include the East Coast Rail Link (ECRL), whereby the excuse cited was that the government was almost bankrupt.


21 August 2018: Tun Dr Mahathir announced the cancellation of the ECRL and 2 natural gas pipeline projects.

20 March 2019: Tun Dr Mahathir announced that the ECRL project would proceed.

5 March 2019: During the Rantau state by-election, Finance Minister Lim Guan Eng hinted that the ECRL would be rerouted to Negeri Sembilan.

Then came the new alignment by PH, or known as the Southern Realignment, starting from Kota Bharu, through Jelebu and Kuala Kelawang in Negeri Sembilan, and thence to Bangi, Kajang and Putrajaya before reaching Port Klang.

A close examination of the ECRL chronology renders it absolutely apparent that PH aces in politicising the ECRL issue.

Selangor state EXCO Dato’ Teng Chang Khim and Negeri Sembilan state EXCO Teo Kok Seong have expressed their dissatisfaction emotionally and by populistically.

Dato’ Teng accuses the Federal Government of bullying the Selangor state government and threatens to not cooperate on the issue of land acquisition, whereas Teo on the other hand, alleges that Negeri Sembilan residents have been betrayed.

In this context, a press conference was held in the morning of 7 April 2021 to discuss the various issues related to the ECRL.

Firstly, the ECRL 3.0 which was recently announced does not follow a new alignment, but reverts to the original alignment which was established by the BN government previously. BN and Perikatan Nasional (PN) will proceed with this alignment. The party responsible for switching the ECRL’s route was PH.

DYMM Sultan Selangor has likewise expressed His Royal Highness’ delight after receiving a briefing by the Transport Minister Datuk Sri Ir Dr Wee Ka Siong on the said alignment.

Secondly, PH altered the route simply due to the Rantau by-election. Back then, many had teased PH by inquiring, “would the route be diverted to Sandakan as a by-election would be held in that area? Or will it be rerouted to all towns as the general election approaches?”

It is obvious that PH assumes the ECRL as an instrument to retaliate whilst neglecting the real needs and interests of the country.

Thirdly, the BN-PN Northern Alignment has allayed the Selangor state government’s worries all this while, when a tunnel will be constructed to avoid the Batu Dam and the surrounding water catchment area, and the Gombak Quartz Ridge which is being established as a Unesco Heritage Site

Additionally, 5 terminals in Selangor will bring economic benefits to Gombak, Semantan and Port Klang.

The Transport Ministry had held 37 consultation meetings with the Malaysia Rail Link Sdn Bhd (MRL), representatives of the ECRL contractors and with 17 agencies in Selangor before deciding to continue with the said alignment.

Dato’ Teng has shut his eyes to the economic returns which will be reaped from this alignment. On the contrary, he accuses the federal Government of bullying. We therefore challenge him to submit a complete, scientific and professional report to support his claims.

Teo’s allegations that PN had betrayed the residents of Negeri Sembilan totally do not make sense at all. Why doesn’t PH admit that PH betrayed the residents of Selangor and other states, when PH modified the route to enter Negeri Sembilan previously?

Therefore, we hope both of them will cease playing up populist sentiments, but instead be pragmatic in defending the rakyat and help to revive our nation’s economy.

 

A comparison between the Northern Alignment and the Southern Alignment for the ECRL

Alignment

Northern (BN and PN)

Southern (PH)

Route

From Mentakab to Port Klang via Bentong, Gombak and Serendah.

After Mentakab, enters Negeri Sembilan before returning to Selangor

Estimated cost

RM50 billion

RM52.28 billion (includes implementing a separate construction for the Serendah Bypass)

Additional benefits

Constructing the Serendah Bypass solves the problem of cargo service congestion faced by KTMB across Kuala Lumpur.

None

Completion date

2027

2027

 

Greater benefits with smaller impacts through the Northern Alignment compared to the Southern Alignment for the ECRL

Alignment

Northern (BN and PN)

Southern (PH)

Water catchment areas

3

At least 4

Land acquisition

4302 lots

6038 lots

Housing areas

11

19

Orang Asli areas

2

7

Malay Reserve Land

2

3

Estimate number of passengers in first year of operations

5.03 million persons

4.07 million persons

 


Facebook link of press conference: https://www.facebook.com/MCAHQ/videos/1197351620715032/

Jacob Lee Yee Yuan
MCA Youth  Spokesperson

-MCA online-

Related Post

EC’s justification on Undi18 unreasonable, implementation must be done immediately

Extension of targeted moratorium on loans repayment reflects togetherness of financial institutions with rakyat amidst Covid-19 woes

Say “NO” to Populist Political Chants

Stop politicising Selangor stimulus package, treat all constituencies equally

Selangor ADUNs must use Covid-19 stimulus package wisely & transparently to benefit residents